top of page
  • Writer's pictureS A

Busting the Metabolism Myth: What "Fast" and "Slow" Metabolism Really Mean

We all know those people: the ones who seem to defy the laws of weight gain, able to indulge in seemingly endless pizza without gaining an ounce. While, on the other hand, some struggle to keep the weight off even with a salad. The explanation often falls back on the elusive concept of metabolism – some have it "fast," others "slow." But what exactly does this mean, and is it truly set in stone?


Metabolism: Beyond the Buzzword

In the weight-loss world, "metabolism" often gets thrown around to explain weight differences. Your metabolism refers to all the biochemical processes that happen inside your body to keep you alive and functioning. These processes include:

  • Breaking down food into usable energy

  • Converting food into building blocks for tissues

  • Removing waste products

  • Regulating body temperature


Mitochondria: Unveiling the Powerhouse Within

Let's ditch the vague terms and delve into the science. Our cells rely on tiny power plants called mitochondria to generate energy by burning fuel (like fat and sugar) and consuming oxygen. These mitochondria are fascinating organelles with a rich evolutionary history.


Cellular Powerhouses with an Ancient Past:  Mitochondria are believed to have originated from free-living bacteria that were engulfed by larger precursor cells billions of years ago. Over time, a symbiotic relationship formed, with the mitochondria providing energy to the host cell and the host cell providing nutrients and protection to the mitochondria. This endosymbiotic theory explains why mitochondria have their own DNA, separate from the cell's nuclear DNA.


The Engine of Cellular Work:  Mitochondria are essential for almost every cellular function. They are the primary site of cellular respiration, the process by which energy is extracted from food molecules like glucose and fat. This energy is then extracted through a molecule called adenosine triphosphate (ATP), often referred to as the cell's energy currency. ATP fuels various cellular activities, from muscle contraction to protein synthesis.



Relevance in Metabolism:  Metabolism refers to the sum of all the chemical reactions in our bodies. It encompasses processes like breaking down food for energy (catabolism) and building new molecules (anabolism). Mitochondria play a central role in metabolism by generating most of the cell's ATP through cellular respiration. The efficiency of mitochondrial function significantly impacts our overall metabolic rate.


Energy Expenditure Primer: Understanding Your Burn Rate

To further investigate the factors affecting weight loss, let's break down what comprises your total daily energy expenditure, essentially the total number of calories you burn each day. This can be helpful in understanding how different factors, might influence weight management.


There are three main components to your daily energy expenditure:

Resting Energy Expenditure (REE) (Also known as Basal Metabolic Rate or BMR): This is the number of calories your body burns at rest to maintain basic life functions, such as breathing, circulation, and cell production. It's measured while you're lying down quietly after not eating anything overnight (fasted).


The primary drivers of your REE are your internal organs like the heart, brain, liver, and kidneys. Muscle and fat tissues also contribute to BMR, but to a lesser extent. Generally, REE makes up a significant portion of your daily calorie burn, ranging from 60% to 75%. However, in highly active individuals, this percentage can drop to 50% or less.


Activity Energy Expenditure (AEE) (Also referred to as Non-Resting Energy Expenditure or NREE): This represents the calories you burn through physical activity. It includes any type of movement, from planned exercise routines to everyday activities like fidgeting, maintaining posture, or even walking around the office. AEE typically makes up 17% to 32% of your total daily energy expenditure, but can be much higher for very active people. We can further break down AEE into two categories:

  • Exercise: This refers to planned and structured physical activities, like weight training, running, or swimming.

  • Non-Exercise Activity Thermogenesis (NEAT): This term refers to the calories burned through all activities that are not formal exercise. The majority of your activity energy expenditure actually comes from NEAT. Examples include fidgeting, walking short distances, standing throughout the day, or even tapping your fingers.


Thermic Effect of Feeding (TEF): This refers to the energy your body uses to digest, absorb, and store the food you consume. The thermic effect of feeding is relatively small, typically accounting for around 8% of your daily calorie expenditure.


Component

Description

Typical Contribution to Daily Expenditure

Resting Energy Expenditure (REE) (BMR)

Calories burned to maintain basic life functions at rest (breathing, circulation, cell production). Measured while fasted and lying down quietly.

60% - 75%

Activity Energy Expenditure (AEE) (NREE)

Calories burned through physical activity (any movement, including fidgeting, posture maintenance, exercise).

17% - 32%

Thermic Effect of Feeding (TEF) 

Energy used to digest, absorb, and store food.

~8%


Muscle Mass and Metabolic Efficiency

While muscle tissue burns more calories at rest compared to fat tissue, there's a catch: highly active individuals often develop a more metabolically efficient way of using energy. Their bodies become very good at extracting energy from nutrients, requiring fewer calories overall to maintain basic functions at rest (REE).


Here's a breakdown of the contributing factors:

Muscle Quality: Intense training can lead to adaptations in muscle fibers, making them more efficient at using oxygen and generating energy. This translates to a lower calorie burn at rest, even though muscle burns more calories per pound than fat.


Metabolic Adaptations: Regular exercise can improve the body's ability to use energy from various sources, including fat and carbohydrates. This efficiency can lead to a lower REE because the body doesn't need to expend as much energy to extract usable fuel from food.


Thermic Effect of Activity (TEF): While REE represents the calories burned at complete rest, highly active individuals often experience an elevated TEF even during rest periods. This means their bodies continue to burn more calories after exercise due to ongoing muscle repair and recovery processes. This extra calorie burning can contribute to a lower percentage of total daily expenditure coming from REE.


Important Note: It's important to remember that REE is just one component of total daily energy expenditure. Even though the percentage of calories burned by REE might be lower in highly active individuals, their overall calorie burn is likely still much higher due to their activity levels (AEE). For example, an athlete with a lower REE due to metabolic efficiency might still burn significantly more calories throughout the day compared to a less active person with a higher REE.


In essence, highly active individuals trade a slightly lower REE for a much higher activity energy expenditure (AEE). This allows them to maintain their high energy demands for training and performance.


Understanding these components of daily energy expenditure is crucial for weight management. By creating a calorie deficit (burning more calories than you consume), you can force your body to tap into stored energy reserves (fat) for fuel, leading to weight loss.


So, how does metabolism affect weight loss?

Several factors can influence your metabolic rate, including:

  • Body composition: Muscle burns more calories at rest than fat. So, individuals with a higher muscle mass tend to have a higher BMR.

  • Age: As we age, our muscle mass tends to decrease, and our BMR naturally slows down.

  • Genetics: Some people are genetically predisposed to have a faster or slower metabolism.

  • Diet: The thermic effect of feeding can influence your metabolism to a small degree. Processing protein can cause a slightly higher thermic effect compared to carbs or fat.


The Truth About Individual Differences

While genetics play a role, a 2022 study [1] published in Science revealed a surprising fact: metabolic rates can vary significantly even among people of the same sex, height, and weight! The study showed a staggering range in calorie burning, from 1,400 to a whopping 5,700 calories per day for individuals with the same body weight.


Muscle vs. Fat: The Calorie-Burning Battleground

While both muscle and fat are essential components of the body, they play vastly different roles when it comes to metabolism. Here's why muscle reigns supreme in the calorie-burning department:

  • Metabolic Activity: Muscle is metabolically active tissue. This means it constantly burns calories, even at rest. Muscle tissue is essentially a furnace, using energy (calories) for various functions like maintaining its structure, repairing itself after exercise, and supporting vital processes within muscle cells. In contrast, fat tissue is metabolically inactive. It primarily serves as an energy storage unit, only burning a minimal amount of calories to maintain itself.


Think of it this way: Imagine you have two roommates:

Roommate Muscle:  This energetic roommate is constantly tidying up, working out, and keeping the place buzzing with activity. All this movement burns calories!

Roommate Fat:  This easy-going roommate spends most of the time relaxing on the couch. While they do need some energy for basic functions, their overall calorie burning is minimal.


Pound for Pound Comparison: At rest, one pound of muscle burns roughly 3-6 calories per day, whereas one pound of fat burns only about 2 calories per day. This may seem like a small difference, but it adds up over time. Let's say you have 20 pounds of muscle. At rest, you'd burn 60-120 calories per day just from your muscle tissue! If you replaced that muscle with fat, you'd only burn 40 calories per day. That's a difference of 20-80 calories burned each day, simply due to the type of tissue you have.


Calorie Burning Comparison: Muscle vs. Fat

Tissue

Calories Burned per Pound (per Day)

Daily Difference (20 lb Muscle vs. 20 lb Fat)

Monthly Difference (20 lb Muscle vs. 20 lb Fat) (assuming 30 days)

Yearly Difference (20 lb Muscle vs. 20 lb Fat)

Muscle

3-6

20-80 calories

0.6-2.4 pounds

7.2-28.8 pounds

Fat

2

-

-

-

Note: Since fat tissue burns fewer calories per day compared to muscle, it has no positive value in the "Difference" columns.


Additional Benefits of Muscle:

Building muscle offers a double whammy for boosting metabolism:

Increased Muscle Mass: As you gain muscle through strength training, your overall metabolic rate increases because you have more metabolically active tissue.


The Afterburn Effect (EPOC): When you engage in strength training, your body continues to burn extra calories even after your workout is finished. This is known as Excess Post-exercise Oxygen Consumption (EPOC). Muscle tissue plays a key role in EPOC, as it requires more energy to repair and rebuild itself after exercise.


Muscle is metabolically superior to fat. It burns more calories at rest, contributes to EPOC, and increases your overall metabolic rate as you gain muscle mass. So, if you're looking to boost your metabolism and burn more calories throughout the day, building muscle is an excellent strategy!


The Bottom Line on Metabolism

Metabolism is often used as a catch-all term for weight loss, but it's a much broader concept encompassing all the biochemical processes that keep you alive and functioning. Understanding the different components of your daily energy expenditure, including Resting Energy Expenditure (REE), Activity Energy Expenditure (AEE), and Thermic Effect of Feeding (TEF), is crucial for effective weight management.


While some factors influencing metabolism, like age and genetics, are beyond our control, there are strategies we can use to optimize it for our goals. Building muscle mass, staying active throughout the day (including NEAT activities like fidgeting and taking the stairs), and maintaining a healthy diet can all contribute to a healthy metabolism and support your weight management efforts.


But what if you could give your metabolism an extra nudge? In the next part of this blog series, we'll explore some interesting tools and strategies that might go beyond the traditional "eat less, exercise more" approach. We'll delve into the science behind weighted vests and how they might influence calorie burning. We'll also discuss the potential drawbacks of severe calorie restriction and explore alternative approaches to weight management. Stay tuned!


[1] Daily energy expenditure through the human life course - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34385400/



Commenti


bottom of page